Adventures with Dr. Lady Cutie Troublemaker

Life is in flux BIG TIME these days. I want to keep in touch with all of my peeps. The Internet is this beautiful thing. I can move to a brand new city and still stay in easy, near-daily contact with the people I love. When I feel connected to the people in my life that matter, I am unstoppable!

30 Days

By Abby at 9:59 pm on Sunday, June 19, 2005

I TiVo’d Morgan Spurlock’s 30 Days. Looks really interesting. Will let you know how it is.

Just watched it. The premise of the show is that each episode is him putting himself in another person’s shoes for 30 days. This first episode was really good. Morgan Spurlock and his fiancee Alex try to live on minimum wage for 30 days. Of course, they are educated, White, and articulate. They don’t have many of the barriers that many people have living on such little money, and they also don’t have the time to build up alliances with other people going through the same thing, so they don’t have time for interdependence. Still, I can forgive that because they do a really good job of sticking to the parameters they set for themselves enough to make the important points about how minimum wage and the American health care system are sub-adequate for basic subsistence. I will definitely be watching this again.

Morgan would have gotten an A+ in my Multiculturalism class. Their major project was a Resistance Project. Here is a section of the guidelines I gave my students at the end of the semester before writing their final paper on the project:

Your Resistance Project is the culmination of all of the work you have done this semester on your resistance group. For this project, you began by completing an approved reading on the group that you feel resistant towards. This prepared you for an interview with a member of that group. In that interview, you had a chance to hear their personal story about being a member of this group. Hopefully, you were able to listen to their story on its own terms and recognize the filters that you yourself had as you listened to their story. Your background and upbringing… in other words, YOUR cultural experiences have caused you to feel some judgments towards this group. That is normal and expected, but hopefully, through this project, you understand just a little bit better than your way of seeing the world is only one of of countless ways of seeing the world. Your last experience was to attend a "happening" related to this group. You may have attended an OUT Meeting or attended a worship service that was different from the type of service you grew up attending. You may have volunteered at a soup kitchen, or gone somewhere else that, prior to this project, you never would have before experienced. I hope that you really challenged yourself and stepped out of your comfort zone.

I see this project as a model for how you address resistance in your life. It is my hope that now, when you encounter difference, your will be aware of your judgments and what it is about you that leads you to have them. I am not naive. I know that you will always continue to judge people who are very different from you. We all do it, but this project has asked you to question your judgments and to place them in the proper context. Your judgments about another person are not truth. You have them for a reason. When you analyze them, you learn a lot more about yourself and your personal comfort zone than you learn about the person you have judged…

Filed under: Politics/Social Justice,Ramblings/Brain Dumps/Opinions,Uncategorized8 Comments »

8 Comments

1
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by Abby's mom

June 20, 2005 @ 5:03 am

I watched it and will watch again. What they went through took guts, and I can’t imagine being in that situation permanently – particularly with children.

Morgan will not be going through all the 30 day challenges himself. Apparently Alex put her foot down and they have gotten others to volunteer.

2
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by Abby

June 20, 2005 @ 7:34 am

Hee. Good for her! It’s some hard stuff he’s doing for the world.

3
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by mike hollihan

June 20, 2005 @ 1:58 pm

I lost the link, but read a story over the weekend that Spurlock fudged some facts in his minimum wage story, including that he had a hard time finding a job that paid just the minimum wage. Many of the jobs he looked at paid at least $7 an hour; he had to quit one because it paid too much, and then another because the deductions took his pay to just above $4 an hour.

I’m skeptical of guys like Spurlock. There was a woman, a teacher, who did a counter-documentary to “Supersize Me” where she ate only the healthy foods on the McDonald’s menu and lost weight! (Search my site for Spurlock to find that link.) Of course, she got no fawning press coverage. Spurlock sets out with his point made and then selectively works with his situation to produce that outcome. Very, very bad science and you should know that, Dr. Abby. He’s dishonest.

4
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by mike hollihan

June 20, 2005 @ 2:01 pm

Oh! Meant to say that Spurlock and his girlfriend found that they could, indeed, live minimum wage for at least a while. Was it hard? Sure. You’ll notice they went back to their comfortable middle-class existence. Seems they were motivated….

5
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by Abby

June 20, 2005 @ 7:38 pm

I’m going to have to disagree with you Mike. I don’t think he is dishonest. He isn’t claiming to be a scientist, nor do *I* claim to be a scientist in all I do. Yes, Spurlock does find evidence to support his pre-existing point, and no, it isn’t scientific. I don’t think it’s supposed to be. In Supersize Me, Morgan sets out to prove a specific point: That the American fast-food lifestyle is incredibly unhealthy. It is, and he does. What makes that movie so powerful is that his health dimishes far beyond what any of his doctors could predict. It isn’t science, but it is good documentary filmmaking.

Reagarding the first episode of 30 Days… Of *course* they went back to their (you said middle, I say UPPER) class lifestyle. I think the point is not to BE people who live at minimum wage. Instead, I think the point is to put themselves in the shoes of people who live that way for a while in order to learn something about the hardships of people who must live that way. I’m very pro-THAT, if that makes sense. They are experiencing something that makes them better advocates. If I try and understand what would make someone be pro-life, I am expanding my world-view in a positive way. That doesn’t mean that I am going to be pro-life myself. It means I am developing my compassion for the experience of others who share this planet with me. Advocacy isn’t scientific. It’s proving a point so that disenfranchised people have a voice, a voice with some strength, and I think Morgan does that.

6
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by mike hollihan

June 21, 2005 @ 12:18 pm

I can discern the outlines of a “reason v. emotion” debate here. Since this is your blog, I’ll defer. 🙂

I did find the links I was talking about: try this Blogcritics post (good comments, too) which leads to the original story I read.

7
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by Abby

June 21, 2005 @ 5:13 pm

Good links. The points about the worker’s comp and cranberry juice are interesting ones, and I’d love to get the full story. Morgan Spurlock is very reponsive on his blog, and I bet if you ask, he’ll respond to this. Maybe I’m more compassionate about this because I DO work with many people stuck in minimum-wage jobs, and I also read Morgan’s blog for a while, and he seems to have his heart in the right place. I’m definitely one to give the benefit of the doubt. It’s a style that serves me well in what I do, but my desire to have the points that he makes made is so overwhelming that I’m willing to forgive minor details such as the ones mentioned. Still, I’m glad to read them and to question his filmmaking as a result. Thanks for the debate, Mike. I always like a nice debate. 😀

8
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by Abby

June 22, 2005 @ 6:58 am

I was just thinking… you know what I love about Morgan Spurlock? I love that we’re having this conversation. If the show just does that, then that’s something!

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.